You may have heard of the recent discovery of a 1,000 year old mummified monk inside a golden statue of a Buddha. This is an example of what is known as a sokushinbutsu, a monk that has undergone the process of self-mummification to achieve salvation and immortality. This occurred primarily during the Middle Ages in Japan, China, India, and Tibet (though I'll talk about Japanese ones in particular). The notion of self-mummification may sound impossible and horribly gruesome, and yes, it is gruesome, but not impossible. Here is a quote from an article I read that was included in the book Rethinking Japan, vol II.

From Massimo Raveri's "In Search of a New Interpretation of Ascetic Experiences" (1990):
"The ascetic...is a rare witness of a perilous intellectual adventure towards an interior dimension of non-duality between ego and the other, between absolute knowledge and total annihilation, between the flow of history and a timeless dimension, that often brings him to the extreme limits of the mind, the body and the language."

This may sound confusing, but it will become clearer when we look at why the monks did this.
But first, how did these monks actually mummify themselves? After spending a period of time wandering among sacred places in Japan, the monk would take refuge in a cave of one of the sacred mountains. In solitude, he (there were no female monks) would spend a period of six years slowly starving himself, first eating only seeds and nuts while engaging in vigorous exercise, and then eating only bark and roots for three years. He would also drink poisonous tea made from the urushi tree that helped dry out his body, allowing his body to be preserved after death. During this time, he meditated and prayed. Eventually, he would be off food entirely, and would drink only water. Then water would go too, and his body would be little more than a living husk.

At this point, other monks would come to help him into a box and seal it. He was left with a bamboo tube for breathing and a rope with a bell that he would ring every day to let the other monks know that he was still alive. The idea was that if he stopped ringing it, he had died. The bamboo tube would then be removed and the monk would be left in the box for another three years, which would give his body time to thoroughly dry out. The monks would then retrieve the body, and if he was successfully mummified, he would be put on display in a monastery and seen as a "living Buddha." If he wasn't successful (i.e., if his body had begun to decay), he would be respected for his endurance, but not worshiped as Buddha. Yes, this is Buddhism we're talking about, not some cult of the dead (the Buddhists that performed self-mummification belonged to the shugendo sect).
Not many monks underwent self-mummification, but there have been enough since the Middle Ages that we have a fair number of them still preserved and worshiped as ascended Buddhas.
So why did they do this? If you look at it in the sense of ascension, wanting their soul to ascend to a higher world/heaven, what did it matter what happened to their bodies, because their soul (or consciousness, or whatever other "force" that is the Buddhism equivalent of the soul) will just leave their body behind? It seems to me that, like many things related to spirituality, emphasizing aspects of the physical world helps serve as preparation for where we are headed. It is a way to gain mental strength: if you can go through years of starving yourself and STILL have your mind attuned to the spiritual, to be able to meditate, and detach yourself from your body's suffering, then it is the final proof that you are ready to become a more enlightened being. Hence, not many monks actually performed this, because you had to be a very dedicated and spiritual sort of person ahead of time. This was really the ultimate test, and if you passed it, people knew that you were an enlightened being, which is why the mummified monks were worshiped after their deaths.
Another interpretation of this mummification was that the monks of the shugendo sect thought that by performing such ascetic acts, that they would develop spiritual powers. Some other practices that they did were meditating under waterfalls (which they still do) and gouging out their own eyes (I'm not sure if they still do this though. I hope not!). If nothing else, these were certainly some of the most determined people around.
The sokushinbutsu were not seen to be committing suicide, but rather, attaining immortality beyond the physical world. The purpose of this ascension was not only for themselves, but for the benefit of humanity: it was believed that the monks would eventually be called upon by the bodhisattva Maitreya to assist in helping humankind in the distant future, returning to the world in an enlightened state for the benefit of others. They were only able to return, however, if their bodies remained preserved on Earth, hence the necessity to preserve them via mummification. I assume, in order to make this work out, that Maitreya would help restore their old dried up bodies, otherwise, it would be quite creepy...
Now to return to the quote with another interpretation of the sokushinbutsu. Becoming a sokushinbutsu can be seen as a metaphor with the monk's body as a symbol that transcends the boundaries of religions. It speaks to people of different creeds who are all pursuing a spiritual path. In his article, Raveri said, "Taking the symbols from the past but often subverting their meanings, the mystic reveals the strength of many religious models and, at the same time, their caducity." (FYI, "caducity" means something that is transient, so in this case, I take it to mean that although specific religions and creeds come and go, the heart of them remains, which is similar throughout the world). The "language" spoken of in the first quote is the language of the unconscious, spoken through allegories such as the mummified bodies of the monks.
We see a spiritual quest represented in a physical symbol, where the "interior dimension of non-duality between ego and other" connects the ideas of immortality (the soul ascending to a higher world) and death (the monk's body; the "other" compared to the soul). Raveri also says that (note that "miira" is the same as sokushinbutsu): "ascetic self-mummification means the achievement of an ambiguous condition which is not life (because the miira does not have all the characteristics of a living person) but which also is not death (because the miira lacks all the classificatory features of a dead person)." So although this is part of a particular Buddhist tradition, it challenges many traditions by bridging the dichotomy of life and death into this strange symbol of the mummified body. It challenges people to think differently, to experience something spiritual by means of the physical.

Yet in all this, there is the danger of focusing too much on the body. After all, if you are starving yourself, it's hard just to ignore your dying body's needs, and at first, it may be even harder than if you are monk eating normally. The potential sokushinbutsu could, in fact, become prey to the same obsessions of starvation that people with anorexia have. Indeed, if you look at a monk starving themselves and an anorectic starving themselves, what they're doing appears similar at a brief glance. Yet what is different is the mentality behind it. The monks are not (in principle, one would hope) starving themselves for any purpose related to their body, but they are using their body as a tool to rise above the physical world and help others by their eventual return to Earth. Also, one would hope that they are not driven by anxieties: they don't focus on the fact that they are eating so little, but take it as part of their spiritual practice and use their remaining energy to meditate and pray.
And so there is a thin line between focus on the body for the sake of the body and using the body as a tool to rise beyond it in a spiritual sense. There is a danger in this fine line, and it will really determine whether the monk has become a true sokushinbutsu, a true Buddha, or if they have fallen prey to the limitations of the physical world. Hence in the bolded quote how the monk ventures in the abyss between "absolute knowledge and total annihilation."

So this practice of becoming a "living Buddha" is certainly fascinating, but I'm not saying it should have been done. It may have been right for some monks, but for the majority of them...well, if all monks did this, no one would be left. And so throughout Japan, the bodies that housed these brave souls continue to be preserved, and perhaps one day, we will see if they have been truly successful if the Buddhas return to Earth.



Note: If you're interested in this topic, I would suggest reading the article I quoted from, though it is incredibly hard to find (not online anywhere, I was lucky enough to find it at my old university library). However, if anyone can't find it and is dying to read it (no pun intended...), I scanned it in, so you can email me and I will send you a copy.




My short story, This Quintessence of Dust, is now available to read online (free) at the Aphelion Webzine!

Click on the cover to Enter!

File:Epicteti Enchiridion Latinis versibus adumbratum (Oxford 1715) frontispiece.jpgEpictetus, a philosopher from Ancient Rome, was one of the most well-known Stoics. He wrote a short book called The Enchiridion (or "Handbook") that outlined how you should live your life to attain tranquility. Despite common beliefs, Stoicism isn't about suppressing emotions, but cultivating a positive outlook on the world by getting rid of negative emotions and desires, and, like Buddhism, not being ruffled by external events.

From Epictetus's The Enchiridion (125 AD):
"A man's master is he who is able to confer or remove whatever that man seeks or shuns. Whoever then would be free, let him wish nothing, let him decline nothing, which depends on others; else he must necessarily be a slave."

Stoics separate things in our lives into two categories: things within our power, and things that are not. Simple enough. What is in our power are things like our opinions, aims, desires, aversions; what's outside our power are our body, job, reputations, and, in general, the external world. Now, we may have some influence over things like our body or our job, but on the whole, it depends on external circumstances beyond our control.
Once we've made this distinction, we can then see what we should concern ourselves with. Obviously, we should only strive to change things that are within our power, because if something isn't in our power to change, what use is there worrying about it? What use is there in bemoaning that a thunderstorm began during your picnic? You have absolutely no control over thunderstorms--it will happen whether you groan about it or not. The Stoics advocate that we have no desires and aversions related to such events. Instead, we should take them as they come, and learn to enjoy them. We should modify our desires to conform to what is and not vainly try to stop things that are beyond our control. If we eliminate desires and hatred of such things in the world, we will be able to attain tranquility.
So we should focus on what we can change. Namely, things that are internal to us. This might lead to change in the external world, but in order to succeed, we must strive to make changes in ourselves rather than the world. Sometimes, it's just about changing our specific goals. We should want to cultivate our reason and imagination. We should want to be moral. We should want to be a good citizen. All these things depend on how we think and act, something that's completely within our power no matter what external circumstances we find ourselves in. It may not be easy, but it isn't beyond our control.
Now, things that are semi-within our power, such as our body or job, have to be given a bit more thought. Instead of making goals such as "I will get a degree in physics," which is external and largely beyond our control, we should change the goal to be internal, such as "I will learn physics and do my best in whatever challenges are put against me." That is something within our power, and is the kind of thing we should make goals about. If we make goals like this, we'll never be disappointed (assuming we follow them through by working as best we can), and so won't be ruffled by external circumstances such as the contingencies that go into getting a degree (the specific questions asked on a test, the whims of the instructors and markers...) that are out of your power. This makes you the sole source of your triumphs and woes, giving you the power to change your life and focus on things that matter.
So that's a bit of background. Looking at the quote again, the first sentence is simply a definition of what it means to be a master or a slave. I think this makes sense: we want to gain certain things and avoid certain things in our lives, and indeed, we live our lives for the sole purpose of gaining or avoiding things (I mean "things" in the most general sense, so this includes internal qualities such as knowledge, love, tranquility, etc.). So if someone can give us what we seek or wish to avoid, then they rule over us, and literally determine our lives. We are a slave to them. For example, if our purpose in life is to be happy, and if the only way to do this is to get an injection of a happiness serum, then whoever controlled the happiness serum controls you, because attaining happiness is all you seek (in this example).

This means that if we desire things that depend on others, then we'll be a slave to them. There are certainly degrees to this, depending on how much you desire it, how much power they have over what you desire compared to how much you control it, etc., but to some extent, you'll be a slave. And unlike the simple example of happiness above, people have numerous desires and aversions, so even if we're only "a bit of a slave" to them all, you will be enmeshed in a web of slavery, each thread pulling you in different directions, preventing you from actually being free.
So we shouldn't desire anything that depends on others, in other words, things that are out of our control. For example, the weather is totally out of your control, so you should never desire anything of it. You shouldn't, according to the Stoics, desire that it will be a nice day, or that you will avoid being out on a bad day. Likewise, your reputation is beyond your control. Do what you will, but people will form opinions about you based on their own ideas and prejudices. Instead, we should focus on the things we can change. This, the Stoics tell us, will lead to tranquility and happiness, and I certainly agree with them. We'll be able to appreciate the world more, be able to view the world with a new sort of wonder. By being free of judgments, we instead experience the world rather than trying to change things we can't. Indeed, Stoics are often very happy people, experiencing the world without jaded indifference or complaining about things never being the way they wanted (this is the same as Buddhists and Taoists).
Thus, we should internalize our desires so that we are our own master. This is really what Stoicism is about: not being ruled by other people, their opinions of us, and unconscious things like the weather, but taking charge of our own lives. In theory, Stoicism isn't complicated: it's principles are quite simple. But putting them into practice is where the challenge lies. As with most ancient philosophies, these aren't just theoretical ideas, but ways to live our lives. That's one of the main differences between philosophy in the present compared to the past. In ancient times, and largely throughout history, philosophy was more comprehensive: it wasn't a discipline you just studied at school and wrote papers about, but a way to live your life. As the historian Paul Veyne said, "To truly be a philosopher was to live out the sect's doctrine, conform one's conduct (and even one's attire) to it, and if need be, to die for it." That last part is just gold: to find something that you would stake your life upon and die for. Because when you follow a philosophy or way of life that you would rather be burned alive for than abandon, then you know you truly belong to it and have found true meaning in your life.


Some Greek philosophers at the British Museum. From left to right: Socrates, Antisthenes, Chrysippus (a Stoic philosopher), Epicurus, and me :)

***

If you'd like to read the Enchiridion, it's very short, and is available for free here. I've also been reading a great book called A Guide to the Good Life: The Ancient Art of Stoic Joy about Stoicism and how to apply it in your life. It's very easy to read and I would recommend it to everyone and anyone.



Pine, Hawk, and Spirit Fungus Giuseppe Castiglione (1688-1766), Qing dynasty: I recently read a book about the wise men of ancient China called the fangshi, a fascinating book that catalogues stories from the lives of these men, involving their predictions, connection to spirits, and the natural magic they wielded. The following quote is attributed to the fangshi Kuan Lu, who lived in the 3rd century (note: a "li" is a distance measurement):

From Doctors, Diviners, and Magicians of Ancient China: Biographies of Fang-shih, compiled by Kenneth DeWoskin (1983)
"When the bright sun mounts the heavens, its light circulates over a vista of ten thousand li. But when it enters the ground, there is not even a ray equal to the glow of a small burning coal. The full moon on the fifteenth day illuminates the night with its clear radiance, so brightly that one can see off in the distance. But when morning comes, its shine cannot even rival that of a mirror. Now, beyond the sun and the moon, there is the systematic regularity of yin and yang. This system of yin and yang is woven into the infinite variety of things. It is in accord with this system that the birds and the beasts are undergoing endless transformations. That being so, how much more must it be true of men! By ingenuity one can gain mastery over this system and with spiritual prowess can grasp the unfathomable."

The fangshi (or "fang-shih", depending on how you want to write it from Chinese), form an important part of Chinese legend and philosophy. They were solitary men who studied Nature and the esoteric arts, and although there weren't any fangshi organizations or groups, each of them discovered similar practices, so are all called "fangshi." Many of them studied the hexagrams of The Book of Changes (The I Ching) to predict future events. For example, the appearance of certain animals, the flight patterns of birds, the weather, etc. can have significant meanings in people's lives and the affairs of a state if they are interpreted properly.
In ancient times, the fangshi were sought after by kings and nobles for their wisdom, most of which revolved around predicting future events. The fangshi also had a connection to the spirit world, where ghosts of those deceased as well as spirits and demons dwell.
Ma_Yuan_-_Dancing_and_Singing-_Peasants_Returning_from_Work: In the quote above, we can see why events in Nature reflect human affairs. It's all about the microcosm and macrocosm: as above, so below. As Nature reflects Heaven (or whatever higher world you want to call it), so does the human world reflect Nature. The human world is at the same time a part of Nature as well as a microcosm of its own. Likewise, when something happens in the world below, there is a response that can be read in Nature and even the heavens. For example, Lu says, "When armies move and people suffer, there is a response among terrestrial things, and that means among the mountains, forests, birds, and beasts." Each world has its own "code" that must be studied to read the meaning behind it and how it connects to ourselves and our society. 
We also see the idea of the rise and fall of certain forces as they take turns in domination. For example, the moon pales next to a light reflected from a mirror in the daytime. This doesn't mean that moon changes, but that different forces "takes turns" dominating, for they are all part of the cycle of yin and yang (two opposite qualities that describe the world). They are connected, ever transforming into one another. Fire into water, love into hate, light into dark. Hence the well-known symbol:

Or something thereof :)
Likewise, in the human world, we may be powerless against, say, a flood, but by ingenuity, we can rise above it by building a sanctuary on high ground. Most people are unable to extend the years of their lives, but it is said that the many of the fangshi found the secret of immortality, or at least, were able to live extended lives (for example, by performing what is known as fetal breathing, a practice that involves sustaining oneself with as little respiration as possible). This is an example of what Lu means when he said, "By ingenuity one can gain mastery over this system and with spiritual prowess can grasp the unfathomable."
The unseen force that flows between beings and events, between the different worlds (which are in truth all connected) is called ch'i. Ch'i is a life force present in the world and all beings within it. Everything is linked by the flow of ch'i. When there is a disturbance in one world, it is reflected in the others, and will manifest in whatever elements are present in that world--so in Nature, creatures like birds respond to the flow of ch'i, and their movements can have a significance. Elements such as fire, earth, air, and water also have a distinctive ch'i, and being some of the most simple substances in Nature, they are more likely to reflect changes in the heavens and human world. For example, storms (air and water) were often seen as portents for state and military affairs.

All of this may seem to be in the realm of pseudo-science, but I think there is some merit to it. From biology and physics (especially quantum physics), we know the world is all connected, and if someone could read the linkages between things, had an eye for perceiving them, they might be able to read it as the fangshi did. One only has to look at someone like Sherlock Holmes to realize that some people have extremely heightened perceptions so that they can perceive details about world that are hidden to others. In many ways, Sherlock Holmes is a later day version of the fangshi.
It's difficult to properly appreciate the understanding people in the past had of Nature, mostly because, on the whole, our society is out of tune with Nature and regards it with scientific principles rather than trying to connect to its more subtle essence that cannot be laid bare by mathematics, but has to be perceived. Imagine how different it would seem to the fangshi and other philosophers who tried to understand the world, such as Druids and shamans. Their way of understanding the world wasn't wrong, nor is ours, but in many ways, theirs was deeper than our own. They had a spiritual understanding of the world as well as a physical one, and were able to navigate how things were connected, in particular, by the subtle signs revealed in Nature. 
That is one of things our science of today is missing. And that, I believe, is where we must reforge our paths if we want to gain a better understanding of our own world and those beyond it.
Click here for more posts in my Quotes of Wisdom series.




You can get a free copy of my historical fantasy short story The StarCompass today! The e-book is on a free promotion until Sunday:
In Canada: https://www.amazon.ca/The-StarCompass-Mary-Jea…/…/B00IC51LT4
In U.S.: https://www.amazon.com/StarCompass-Mary-Jean-…/…/B00IC51LT4…

"A Soul Wanderer never knows. He wanders; he makes his own path through the
heights of the universe."

-Sio Larwick


Follow Me on Pinterest

Mary-Jean's books

The Printer's Devil
The Crystal Cave
The Picture of Dorian Gray
The Lost Prince
The Fellowship of the Ring
The Hobbit
Rise of the Darklings
The Fire King
Clockwork Angel
Jane Eyre
Wuthering Heights
The Lost World
Around the World in Eighty Days
The Sum of All Men
Brotherhood of the Wolf
Wizardborn
The Lair of Bones
Sons of the Oak
Worldbinder
The Wyrmling Horde


Mary-Jean Harris's favorite books »
Powered by Blogger.